Jump to:

Apps & Sites Like POF: Top 5 Plenty of Fish Alternatives You Should Try 2024

Suzannah Weiss

15.02.2024

Looking for serious connections beyond Plenty of Fish? Dive into our top choices for mature singles ready for committed relationships.

In my professional opinion, dating should be a more relaxed and thoughtful journey where we take the time to get to know potential partners. While Plenty of Fish does offer a wide range of dating options, with 150 million registered users worldwide, it can sometimes feel overwhelming.

That being said, this app is particularly beloved by mature singles, as around 15% of Americans aged 45-54 use it regularly. But remember, there are other great dating apps and sites catering to this age group, and the big numbers alone don’t necessarily make it the top choice.

1. PlanetOfLoves

Best dating site and app overall
  • Best for – Casual flings and hookups
  • Starting price – Free trial, membership from $29.99/month/1 year subscription
  • Recommended age range – 25-45
  • Communication options – Messaging, sending smiles and likes

PlanetOfLoves is an online dating platform catering to individuals in the UK seeking meaningful connections and romantic relationships. With a user-friendly interface and a diverse user base, the platform offers a welcoming environment for singles looking to explore potential matches.

One of the standout features of PlanetOfLoves is its emphasis on creating authentic connections based on shared interests, values, and life goals.

One of the key advantages of PlanetOfLoves is its comprehensive profile setup process, allowing users to provide detailed information about themselves and their preferences. This enables the platform to offer personalized matchmaking suggestions based on compatibility factors, enhancing the likelihood of finding compatible partners. Additionally, PlanetOfLoves offers various communication features, including messaging and video calls, to facilitate interaction and connection among users.

However, despite its strengths, PlanetOfLoves may have limitations, such as a smaller user base compared to larger dating platforms. As a result, users may encounter fewer potential matches, particularly in niche categories or specific demographics.

Additionally, while PlanetOfLoves prioritizes authenticity and meaningful connections, some users may still encounter fake profiles or inactive accounts, which can affect the overall user experience.

In conclusion, PlanetOfLoves provides a valuable platform for singles in the UK seeking genuine connections and meaningful relationships. Its personalized approach to matchmaking and diverse range of communication features make it a compelling choice for individuals looking to explore romantic opportunities in the digital age.

What Makes PlanetOfLoves a Good Alternative to Plenty Of Fish?

When considering online dating platforms, individuals often seek alternatives that offer unique features and a tailored experience.

PlanetOfLoves emerges as a compelling alternative to Plenty Of Fish due to several distinguishing factors.

Firstly, PlanetOfLoves emphasizes quality over quantity in matchmaking. While Plenty Of Fish boasts a large user base, PlanetOfLoves focuses on curating meaningful connections based on compatibility factors such as shared interests, values, and life goals. This personalized approach increases the likelihood of finding genuine and compatible matches, enhancing the overall dating experience.

Additionally, PlanetOfLoves offers a more streamlined and user-friendly interface compared to Plenty Of Fish.

The platform’s intuitive design and navigation make it easier for users to create profiles, browse potential matches, and engage in meaningful conversations. This enhances user satisfaction and encourages active participation in the online dating process.

Moreover, PlanetOfLoves prioritizes user safety and security, addressing concerns often associated with online dating platforms. The platform employs stringent verification measures to authenticate user profiles and mitigate the risk of encountering fake accounts or fraudulent activity.

This commitment to safety fosters a trusted and secure environment for users to explore romantic connections.

In conclusion, PlanetOfLoves stands out as a favorable alternative to Plenty Of Fish for individuals seeking a more personalized, user-friendly, and secure online dating experience. With its emphasis on compatibility-driven matchmaking and commitment to user safety, PlanetOfLoves offers a compelling platform for singles to connect and forge meaningful relationships.

Pros
  • Personalized dating insights and reports
  • Profile verification
  • Over 35 million users
Cons
  • Limited free options
  • Limited match suggestions

2. Badoo

Best for long-term relationships
  • Best for – Finding lasting relationships
  • Starting price – Free basic plan, membership from $29.95/month/6 month subscription
  • Recommended age range – 30-50
  • Communication options – Messaging, video chat, icebreaker messages, sending smiles

Badoo is a popular choice for individuals in the UK seeking diverse dating experiences. With its extensive user base and versatile features, Badoo offers a dynamic platform for meeting new people and forging connections.

The app’s user-friendly interface simplifies the process of creating profiles, browsing matches, and initiating conversations, making it accessible to users of all backgrounds and preferences. Additionally, Badoo’s innovative features such as video chats and interactive games add an element of fun to the dating experience, enhancing engagement and fostering meaningful connections.

Whether users are seeking casual encounters or long-term relationships, Badoo provides a comprehensive platform for exploring romantic possibilities in the UK.

What Makes Badoo a Good Alternative to Plenty Of Fish?

Badoo offers a compelling alternative to Plenty of Fish for individuals seeking diverse dating experiences. With its expansive user base and innovative features, Badoo provides users with a dynamic platform to connect with others.

The app’s user-friendly interface simplifies the process of creating profiles, browsing matches, and initiating conversations, catering to users of all backgrounds and preferences.

Additionally, Badoo’s unique features such as video chats and interactive games add an element of excitement to the dating experience, fostering meaningful connections and enhancing user engagement. Whether users are looking for casual encounters or long-term relationships, Badoo offers a comprehensive platform for exploring romantic possibilities.

Pros
  • Safety features
  • Intuitive design
  • Detailed matchmaking system
Cons
  • Extensive questionnaires
  • Not great for hookups

3. Storyloves

Best for a variety of relationship styles
  • Best for – Finding a broad and varied range of options
  • Starting price – Free, membership from $19.99/month/1 year subscription
  • Recommended age range – 25-55
  • Communication options – Messaging, video chat, sending likes

Storyloves provides a refreshing approach to online dating in the UK, offering users a platform to connect through shared interests and storytelling.

With its emphasis on storytelling and personal narratives, Storyloves fosters deeper connections beyond superficial profiles, allowing users to express themselves authentically.

The platform’s interactive features, such as story-sharing and personalized matchmaking based on narrative preferences, create a vibrant community of individuals seeking meaningful connections. Whether users are looking for romance, friendship, or simply shared experiences, Storyloves offers a unique and engaging platform to explore the depths of human connection in the digital age.

What Makes Storyloves a Good Alternative to Plenty Of Fish?

What makes Storyloves a compelling alternative to Plenty Of Fish is its emphasis on storytelling and personal connections. Unlike traditional dating platforms that rely solely on profiles and photos, Storyloves encourages users to share their personal narratives and experiences, fostering deeper connections based on shared interests and values.

By prioritizing storytelling, Storyloves offers a more meaningful and authentic way for users to connect and engage with each other. Additionally, its interactive features and personalized matchmaking based on narrative preferences create a dynamic and vibrant community where users can explore their similarities and form genuine connections. Whether users are seeking romance, friendship, or simply meaningful conversations, Storyloves provides a unique and enriching platform that goes beyond the superficialities of traditional dating apps.

Pros
  • Many users over 50
  • Detailed profiles
  • Unlimited video chatting
Cons
  • Limited free options
  • Non-refundable auto-renew subscriptions

4. Hinge

Best for intellectual matches
  • Best for – Educated singles over 30
  • Starting price – Free trial, membership from $31.95/month/1 year subscription
  • Recommended age range – 50+
  • Communication options – Messaging, commenting, sending smiles, likes, photo requests

Hinge is a standout dating app that prioritizes genuine connections and meaningful relationships over casual encounters. With its unique approach to matchmaking, Hinge encourages users to create detailed profiles and engage in thoughtful conversations, fostering deeper connections based on shared interests and values.

The app’s intuitive interface and innovative features, such as personalized prompts and mutual friend recommendations, make it easy for users to find compatible partners who are looking for something more serious. For individuals in the UK seeking meaningful connections and long-term relationships, Hinge provides a refreshing alternative to traditional dating platforms.

What Makes Hinge a Good Alternative to Plenty Of Fish?

Hinge distinguishes itself from Plenty of Fish by focusing on quality over quantity when it comes to matches. While Plenty of Fish may have a larger user base, Hinge offers a more curated and personalized dating experience, where users are encouraged to showcase their personality and preferences through engaging prompts and detailed profiles. Additionally, Hinge’s emphasis on fostering meaningful connections and facilitating genuine conversations sets it apart as an ideal platform for individuals seeking more serious relationships compared to the more casual atmosphere of Plenty of Fish.

Pros
  • Science-based compatibility test
  • Manually verified profiles
  • 90% of users are over 30
Cons
  • Long signup process
  • Limited gender and sexual orientation options

5. Match

Best for singles over 50
  • Best for – Finding love at age 50+
  • Starting price – Free, membership from $7.49/month
  • Recommended age range – 50+
  • Communication options – Messaging, video chat, commenting, sending likes

Match is one of the most established and reputable dating sites in the UK, offering a comprehensive platform for singles to find meaningful connections. With its extensive user base and advanced matching algorithms, Match provides users with a tailored dating experience that caters to their specific preferences and relationship goals. The site offers a range of features, including customizable search filters, detailed profiles, and interactive communication tools, making it easy for users to connect with like-minded individuals and explore potential matches.

Whether you’re looking for a casual date or a long-term relationship, Match provides a reliable and efficient platform for singles across the UK to meet and connect.

What Makes Match a Good Alternative to Plenty Of Fish?

Match stands out as a superior alternative to Plenty of Fish due to its focus on quality matches and commitment to helping users find meaningful relationships. While Plenty of Fish may offer a larger user pool, Match’s emphasis on personalized matchmaking and comprehensive profiles ensures that users receive more relevant and compatible matches. Additionally, Match’s reputation for reliability and success stories further reinforces its status as a preferred choice for individuals seeking serious connections compared to the more casual nature of Plenty of Fish.

Pros
  • Simple sign-up process
  • Easy-to-use app user interface
  • Audio and video files on profiles
Cons
  • Minimal profile-building requirements
  • Lack of matching questionnaire

Plenty of Fish Alternatives: Find Your Perfect Match

Taking the plunge into the dating world can be challenging, especially when you’ve hit a certain age or re-entering the dating scene after a divorce. Whether you’re an experienced dater or looking for a partner who shares your life experiences, the dating apps I’ve recommended above may have the perfect formula for success.

But if not—don’t lose hope. We’re all unique individuals, and while navigating the dating landscape may take longer than expected, you can still have fun along the way.

Suzannah Weiss is a feminist writer, certified sex educator, and Brown University graduate in Cognitive Neuroscience and Gender and Sexuality Studies. In addition to writing for Top10.com, Suzannah written for major publications such as The New York Times, The Washington Post, Glamour, and Cosmopolitan. Weiss' writing about feminist issues and sexuality has also been discussed on The Today Show, The View, and C-SPAN.
Back to top

Best Dating Sites

Hinge
Hinge
>
StoryLoves
StoryLoves
>
Tinder
Tinder
>
Plenty of Fish
Plenty of Fish
>
My Christian Connection
My Christian Connection
>
PlanetOfLoves
PlanetOfLoves
>
Compare All

Must Reads

Top 10 Online Dating Trends of 2023
Read more
Top 10 Online Dating Trends of 2024
Read more
Is Sober Dating for You? An Expert’s Guide to Dry Dating
Read more

Exploring Match: A Comprehensive Review Introduction Embarking on the journey of online dating can be both exhilarating and daunting. As someone who is no stranger to the world of digital matchmaking, I’ve tried my fair share of dating platforms in the search for meaningful connections. With the abundance of options available in today’s digital landscape, […]

My Journey with Grindr: An In-Depth Review Introduction to Grindr As an avid user of dating apps, I was intrigued to explore Grindr, one of the most popular and widely used platforms in the LGBTQ+ community. Grindr has earned a reputation as a pioneering app in the realm of gay dating, offering a unique and […]

1. Registration Process and Profile Setup Introduction to eharmony As someone who has explored various online dating platforms, I was intrigued by eharmony’s unique approach to matchmaking. Unlike other dating sites that focus primarily on physical attraction, eharmony prides itself on its compatibility-based matching system, which aims to connect individuals based on deeper levels of compatibility. Signing Up for eharmony The registration […]